Two pale coastal cottages beside a quiet green lawn and pink-tan muhly grass in soft Florida autumn sunlight.

Who Sets the Price of a WindMark Beach Home Now

The D.R. Horton listing for 195 Needle Rush Drive at WindMark Beach is a two-story, four-bedroom house with 2,245 square feet. It is marked down to $464,900 from $494,900 and featured as the builder's home of the week. Further down the same builder page, 1949 Backwater Road also has 2,245 square feet and is listed at $499,750, with a special interest rate advertised beside it. That is a $34,850 gap between two new homes of the same size in the same community, and the builder set both prices.

Anyone comparing homes at WindMark Beach is pricing against one builder. That builder has years of homesites still to sell and has already shown it will cut prices and add financing incentives to keep homes moving. That changes how a buyer should read any WindMark listing, new or resale.

The builder's list in mid-November 2026

As of mid-November 2026, D.R. Horton's standard WindMark series shows five homes for sale, priced from $449,900 to $499,900. They range from 1,846 to 2,415 square feet, and two more are marked under contract. By square foot, those five asking prices run from about $207 to $244, with a median near $219. The low end belongs to 137 Hollis Circle at $499,900 for 2,415 square feet. The high end is 190 Needle Rush Drive, where $449,900 buys 1,846 square feet. On this list, the smallest house carries the highest per-foot price.

The Emerald series is the builder's step-up line at WindMark. It shows eight homes listed from $499,900 to $799,900, with one under contract. Those homes run from 2,073 to 2,745 square feet, or about $241 to $336 per square foot, with a median near $291. Across the two series, the builder advertises WindMark homes starting at $432,900.

Florida Realtors counts Bay and Gulf counties together as the Panama City metro. In September 2026, the metro's median single-family sale price was $367,959, up 2.5% from September 2025, on 378 closed sales. Even the builder's lowest WindMark price is well above that regional median. The gap is the premium for a new house on St. Joseph Bay, and the same company sets that premium for all 13 of its listed homes.

WindMark was first priced for a different buyer

None of this was the original plan. In its report for the year ending December 31, 2003, the St. Joe Company listed WindMark Beach Phase I as 110 planned units on about 80 acres, with sales starting in 2001 and 100 sold by the end of 2003. St. Joe was building the houses itself then. It priced its Phase I homes at about $950,000 and lots from $90,000 to more than $900,000. Phase II was planned for 1,550 units on 2,000 acres, with homes from $315,000 to more than $1 million and lots from $200,000 to more than $1 million. Sales were set to begin in 2005.

The plan changed within a few years. Florida Trend reported in March 2007 that St. Joe had dropped its homebuilding operations the year before to focus on land development. In a May 2008 earnings release, the company tied impairment charges to continuing declines in sales and listing prices in its main communities. So the WindMark homes standing today come from two different sales plans. The early homes were sold under a luxury price schedule. The later neighborhoods were sold by a volume builder.

How the builder arrived, and what it charged at first

D.R. Horton bought 64 WindMark lots in 2017. In February 2019 St. Joe announced a second contract with Horton for the Village Center East and Creekside neighborhoods, and said WindMark then had 77 existing homes and 14 under construction. In the company's release, Bridget Precise, then St. Joe's vice president of residential development, said "Demand for new single-family residences remains high in this unique community." The release said Horton would also handle the sales and expected homes to be available in early 2020, "starting in the $300,000's."

So in its first few years at WindMark, the builder raised its starting price from the $300,000s to the current $432,900. The community has also grown past the 91 finished and in-progress homes it had in early 2019. St. Joe's project updates page now lists Horton homes in Village Center East, Creekside and WindMark North. The company's builder page describes Horton's homes as pre-approved floor plans. On its own pages, the builder lists standard WindMark plans from 1,799 to 2,415 square feet and four Emerald plans from 2,063 to 2,745 square feet. Those plan ranges fit most of the current resale buyer's search, which is why so many WindMark comparisons end up on the builder's price list.

645 homesites still to come

The supply behind that list is what turns the builder from one seller into the one that sets prices. St. Joe's quarterly filing for the period ending September 30, 2026 counts 645 WindMark Beach homesites in its pipeline. Of those, 171 are in development, 135 are in engineering or permitting and 339 are in concept planning. The same filing says homesites in its multi-phase communities, WindMark included, are "sold primarily to homebuilders and on a limited basis to retail customers."

That is fewer than half of the 1,550 units St. Joe planned for Phase II in 2003. It is still several times the 77 homes WindMark had in 2019. For a buyer, the pipeline means new construction at WindMark will keep coming for years. A builder with that much land ahead of it can cut the price on a finished spec home, as it did on Needle Rush Drive, and advertise a special rate on the next one. An individual seller cannot match either move on the same terms.

That cuts both ways. A buyer looking at a resale home at WindMark has a current, public, per-square-foot benchmark built by the most motivated seller in the community. An owner listing an older home is pricing against new construction and a financing incentive in the same community.

The Town Center changed hands in July

The community's commercial core also has a new owner. In its third-quarter 2026 results, St. Joe reported selling the WindMark Beach Town Center for $10.3 million in July 2026. Our summer look at the Village Center covered its tenants, from The Mill Mercantile & Social to the D.R. Horton model home. The sale doesn't change the neighborhood amenities St. Joe describes, such as the zero-entry Village Center pool, the playground and the Village Green amphitheater. It does mean St. Joe no longer owns the shops and restaurant space a buyer walks past on the way to those amenities.

St. Joe's homeowner page names Burg Management as the WindMark association manager. Buyers can request the current dues schedule and community documents there for any home they are comparing, new or resale.

Reading a WindMark listing against the builder's list

With a production builder setting the reference price, a few comparisons do most of the work at WindMark.

Price per square foot is the first check, measured against the series the home most resembles. A resale home near 2,200 square feet asking well above the $207 to $244 range of the standard series has to show what a new standard-series home lacks. That could be its location in the community, its finish or its lot. A home in Emerald's size range can be checked against the $241 to $336 range of the Emerald listings.

Terms matter as much as prices. The builder is currently pairing some listings with a price cut and others with an advertised rate special. That is a total-cost offer a resale seller may need to answer with a lower price or a seller credit, and a buyer can ask for the same.

The year a house was sold new also tells you what it was priced against. A home from the early St. Joe phases was sold under a 2003 price schedule that put company-built homes near $950,000. A home in Village Center East, Creekside or WindMark North was sold off a pre-approved plan list that started in the $300,000s in 2020. Both are WindMark Beach on a listing sheet, but they were priced for different buyers from the start.

The builder's prices above are a snapshot from mid-November 2026, and spec homes sell and get repriced without notice. Anyone writing an offer should pull that day's list.

If you're weighing a WindMark home against the builder's current list, or deciding how to price an older WindMark home against it, Beach Properties Real Estate Group can put a specific address next to the comparisons above. Contact Us to set a time.

Work With Us

We pride ourselves in providing personalized solutions that bring our clients closer to their dream properties and enhance their long-term wealth. Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!

Follow Us on Instagram